Ranking XTC’s album openers

UNITED STATES – JANUARY 28: Photo of XTC and Colin MOULDING and Dave GREGORY and Andy PARTRIDGE and Terry CHAMBERS; L-R: Dave Gregory, Colin Moulding, Terry Chambers, Andy Partridge – posed, studio, group shot (Photo by Ebet Roberts/Redferns)

Longtime HTV readers know I came around to XTC later than their claque expected. Gifted melodists working in the era of punk, Colin Moulding and Andy Partridge worked up a flop sweat to deny those gifts in their early years; only the Brits could get away with a vocal like Partridge’s in “Radios in Motion.” Matters got easier in 1984-1986 when the psychedelic necrophilia of the Dukes of Stratophear project produced more straightforward material than the dissonances of The Big Express offered. Which is why the baited nostalgia of “Peter Pumpkinhead” offends me. Imagine playing Nonesuch after hearing about the band’s reputation! Few putative melodic masters sound so ugly.

Yet I appreciate gestures like the Stratosphear’s “25 O’Clock,” a catchier version of Bill Wyman’s “In a Lonely Land.”

The Hague

The Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead

Meh

Garden of Earthly Delights
Wake Up

Sound, Solid

Vanishing Girl
Playground
Runaways
Meccanik Dancing (Oh We Go!)
Beating of Hearts

Good to Great

Respectable Street
Life Begins at the Hop
Making Plans for Nigel
River of Orchids
Summer’s Cauldron
25 O’Clock
Radios in Motion

3 thoughts on “Ranking XTC’s album openers

  1. Good lord, how I hated “Nonesuch.” My fandom ended there. Then to be followed by Partridge’s stupid recording strike against Virgin Records helped matters not a whit.

Leave a comment