Ranking the films of David Fincher

On first glance, the stylish MTV videos he directed for stars and wannabes look like his strongest work. So much of David Fincher’s film career consists of genre efforts with chic staging of violence. But like Otto Preminger the lumbering pace of bureaucracies and the sturdiness of institutions fascinate him: police departments (Seven, Zodiac), Harvard administrators (The Social Network), marriage (Gone Girl), masculinity (Fight Club), Brad Pitt (pick three). Few of his films reward further study, despite the precision of their visual design; The Curious Case of Benjamin Button and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo are rebukes to the notion that movies should be more than excuses or precise visual design. The exception: Zodiac (2007), an Unsolved Mysteries episode whose body count wears down a generation of Bay Area investigators.

The Hague

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

Meh

Mank
Gone Girl
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
Panic Room
Alien 3

Sound, Solid

Seven
Fight Club
The Game

Good to Great

Zodiac
The Social Network

2 thoughts on “Ranking the films of David Fincher

  1. Interesting list. Panic Room wasn’t that bad. Maybe Nicole Kidman would have been better there (she was originally cast), but Jodie Foster provided it with her own intelligent aura, shall I put this way. If I had to pick my favourite Fincher film it would be Seven. His trademarks are all over it and Pitt was both a blessing and a curse for that film – same can now be said of Spacey, obviously.

Leave a comment